This Grain Gathering (GG) 2016 workshop aimed to demystify the technique and formulation involved in creating whole-grain pastries that showcase the grain and stand out on their own.
It was taught jointly by Jeff Yankellow (who was a member of Bread Bakers Guild Team USA 2005, which won a gold medal at the Coupe du Monde de la Boulangerie,) and Jonathan Bethony (who until recently was baker-in-residence at The Bread Lab).
In his intro to the class, Jeff said that while bread was headed in the right direction, the same couldn’t be said of pastry. In fact pastry had become a competition of looks. Bakers were achieving great looks with poor techniques: to get beautiful croissants, they had taken water out. The dough had become too dry and people had started to assume that croissants and brioches were made from low-hydration, stiff doughs.
But hydration is not a competition. It is based on how the dough feels. What made bread better was adding water. Why not do the same with croissants and sweet dough?
Also of paramount importance is the quality of the grain the baker uses. Jeff uses hard red spring wheat that is milled silky fine. The flour should still have its integrity and be able to stick together when squeezed. It is used unsifted.
Coarse flour makes bread or pastry very dense.
The technique and ingredients are simple. Baking is a personal journey. What’s your definition of what’s good? Being a baker is learning to fail. It can be frustrating because you don’t get a second chance right away but ultimately failing is your best learning tool.
Whole-Grain Croissants
The whole-grain croissant dough is 97% hydration.
Formula
Ingredient list not available at the moment. I am looking for it!
Note: Butter for roll-in: 250 g (25% based on dough weight)
Method
Levain
- Mix ingredients until incorporated. Leave at room temperature for 4 hours
Final dough
- Mix flour and water 1 to 2 minutes to incorporate. Use warm water to compensate for cold milk.
- Autolyse 30 minutes.
- Add remaining dough ingredients. Mix at low speed to bring the dough together, 2-3 minutes.
DDT: 73-76°F
- Ferment for 2 hours at room temp. Place in fridge for up to 12 hours.
- Fold dough at 1, 2, and 3 hours. The last fold is completed after the dough has been refrigerated for one hour.
- Roll out the dough three times as long as it is wide and complete a single fold, with no butter, to build strength.
- Let rest 60-90 minutes, covered, in refrigerator.
- Prepare butter block to 55-60% (cool but plastic, not creamy). It should be half the size of the dough block.
- Cut off the edges of the dough and put them in the middle.
- Lock in the butter.
- Laminate with two single (envelope) folds.
- Let the dough rest in the refrigerator, covered, for 30-45 minutes, keep the butter cold but plastic. Do not allow the butter to get cold or harden.
- Roll dough out to desired size.
- Cut as needed and shape for croissants.
- Proof for 90-120 minutes at room temperature. Egg wash.
- Bake at 375°F with steam in a convection oven or at 400°F in a static oven, about 15-18 minutes.
- Time and temperature will vary depending on oven and size of croissant.
- Why an autolyse? The idea of course is to hydrate the flour. The fiber absorbs a ton of water and it needs time to soak it up. Remember, you are not trying to make a white croissant. You want to taste the grain and you want the croissant to be flaky and light. The autolyse does part of the work for you. Consider the dough before and after the autolyse in these two pictures:
- Jeff advises adding a bit of diastatic malt, for color and also because the formula calls for only 9% sugar (although you can go as high as 11-12% sugar.)
- As for the levain, it brings out the flavor of the grain and gives a bit of acidity overnight. Any levain will do.
- By short levain, one means a high percentage of starter fermented for a short amount of time.
- Every fold must be a good strong fold.
- Retarding is really important for whole-grain (more flavor). Even for cookies and scones.
Whole-grain sweet dough
Eggs included, the whole-grain sweet dough formula calls for 95% hydration.
- You need 500 g of dough per loaf.
- Jeff uses the same flour as for the croissants.
- The autolyse should be at least 20-30 minutes.
- Very gentle mixing. We let the fermentation do the work.
- You don’t have to make a milk levain. You can use water
Formula
Method
Levain
Mix ingredients until incorporated. Leave at room temperature for 4 hours.
Final Dough
DDT = 73-76°F
- Mix the flour, milk and eggs to incorporate.
- Autolyse for 30 minutes.
- Add the levain, sugar, salt, and yeast. Mix by hand or in first speed until dough comes together and shows signs of strength, 3-4 minutes.
- Let rest 15 minutes.
- Add soft butter and mix by hand or in first speed until dough comes back together, 3-4 minutes.
- Roll dough into tight ball. Place in bowl and cover.
- Let rest 60 minutes at room temperature. Stretch and fold the dough.
- Again let rest 60 minutes at room temperature. Stretch and fold the dough.
- Place the dough in the refrigerator.
- After 60 minutes in the refrigerator, stretch and fold the dough a third time. Return to the refrigerator for 12-18 hours.
This whole-grain dough is versatile and lends itself to many savory or sweet interpretations. Jeff and Jonathan provided two formulas, one for babka, the other for povetica (both available upon request in jpeg format). But my favorites were the two lovely breakfast pastries they made with this dough. I sure wouldn’t mind waking up to such virtuously sinful deliciousness.
Tyler Shelley says
I’m so glad you posted this. Thank you. I had been desiring to know for quite some time how these men were making whole grain croissants. Also, I would love to have the formulas for babka and povetica.
mc.farine says
Okay, I’ll send them to you. MC
Georges says
Hello,
Would you mind sharing the formulas for the croissants and babka please?
Breadstorm doesn’t exist anymore and I am really, really excited to try high hydration whole-wheat croissants! These are like the holy grail for me.
Regards
mc.farine says
Hello Georges, just sent you the babka formula. I don’t have one for the croissants.
Enjoy!
MC
Megan says
Thank you soo much for the lovely recap of the Grain gathering! I wish I could have attended. I too, would love the recipes for babka and povetica- can you please email them to me? I love to bake, especially with whole grains!
mc.farine says
Hi Megan, I just emailed the formulas to you. I too love baking with whole grains!
Susan Eipert says
I’ve experimented a little with whole grain sweet doughs – and would love to have the formulas for povetica and babka.
Thanks so much for reporting on the Grain Gathering – to those of us not there.
mc.farine says
Hi Susan, I just sent them to you. I am glad you liked the post!
Rod says
Hi Marie-Claude,
I have followed you blog for several years now since being introduced to this site by Charles Kutler, a home baker whom you have met several years ago while you two were at Gerard Rubaud’s at the same time. I have enjoyed your posts, with the obvious exception of the loss of your grandson, my sincere sympathy. I thank you for attending the Grain Gathering as I feel I am almost there by reading your entries in your blog. I was introduced to the short/young levain technique by following pipsbread on Instagram but now I read with interest Josey Baker, Jonathan Bethony and Jeff Yankellow were all using this method with whole grains. I would like to try this and go ” all in” with the babka to fully challenge the gluten development properties of dough with chocolate and butter. You mentioned the babka and provetica recipes were available in jpeg format on request. If you could be so kind to email the recipes I would be indebted. Thank you again as I look forward to more posts.
Rod
mc.farine says
Thank you for your kind words, Rod. I just emailed you the formulas. Happy baking!
MC
mc.farine says
Hi Rod, thank you for your kind words. I just emailed you the formulas. Happy baking!
MC
Joseph abrakjian says
Hello MC,
Thank you for reporting on the grain gathering year after year, you sure are doing your part in keeping the community knit together.
It’s my only way to get updated on what’s happening up there through your reporting…
Can I also get the formulas provetica and bubka
Thank you greatly
Joseph
mc.farine says
Hello Joseph,
Thank you for your kind words. I am happy to have an opportunity to do my bit!
I just emailed you the formulas.
All the best, MC
Veronica says
Hello, yes, thank you so much for such a great posting!!! I also would love to have the recipe for babka and povetica, would appreciate it so much, blessings!!
mc.farine says
Hello Veronica, I just emailed you the formulas. Have fun! MC
Megan says
Hi , MC!
I just made the babka from the recipe you sent me, with some creativity on my part because I forgot that there was a babka page 2 😉 So yummy!
Upon reviewing page 2, I noticed that the recipe mentions chocolate chips and cinnamon sugar in the filling- Any chance you have the quantities for those? Or, is it just however much we think is good?
Thank you!!
anita laico says
Love your post, wish more baking was done on the east coast so we could visit and join the fun.
Would you please send the formulas for the babka and povetica, I promise to report back. Thanks
Angie Wu says
Hi,
I stumbled upon your website and really love it! You did a very good reports on those artisan bakers. Do you have any suggestions for bakeries to visit in Seattle area? I have been to Bakery Nouveau, Macrina and Midori Bakery, all made wonderful products! I especially love Midori’s kouign-amann. If you have suggestions for other bakery to visit in Seattle area, please let me know. =)
On the side note, can I have the recipe for the baka and povitica? Thanks again!
mc.farine says
Thank you, Angie! Unfortunately I no longer live in the Seattle area and you have already been to the bakeries I knew best. But there are others: Columbia City Bakery, Tall Grass Bakery for instance. Probably others I don’t know about. One I know well and love is Breadfarm but that is about 90 minutes north of Seattle. I don’t know if you plan to travel that far? I will send you the recipes. Thanks for visiting!
David says
Hi,
Thank you for your sharing on the whole grain post. I have learned a lot from your sharing! I look forward to read about your sharing on this year’s grain gathering! I hope i’m not too late but would you be able to share the formula for babka and povetica? Thank you!
mc.farine says
Thank you, David! Yes, I will send the formula.
Juli Farkas says
Hi MC, I’d love to get better at whole grain sweet dough, I’m in sunny London and love your blog. Would you be kind enough to send me the recipe for the Babia and povetica? My best
Juli
mc.farine says
Sure! I’ll send it right away.
Thanks for stopping by, Juli!
Peter says
Hi MC, I love your blog! I’ve just been getting into whole grain baking and this post and your others about Dave Miller have been so helpful. Could you please send me the formulas for the babka and povetica?
Thanks,
Peter
Michael Lloyd says
The discreption of povetica sounds much like a type of popular pastry baked by the Czechs here in Central Texas, the kolache. My family has been baking the kolache since immigrating from Bohemia just after the Civil War. My Granny, who taught me how to bake many Czech and German recipes, was born in one of the Czech communities but did not learn English until she was a teenager. Please email the formulas and where do I find the whole wheat flour that is used in the BreadLab?
mc.farine says
Hello Michael, I will email you the formulas but unfortunately I can’t help you with the flours. My suggestion is to use what’s available to you locally and play around with the percentages until you get the results you like. How interesting that you have a similar pastry in your family history. Are you referring to the Texas hill country? Are there any specific bakeries you would recommend for kolaches?
Roger Stambaugh says
I am now baking in the bread lab with 100% extraction ancient grains. Most of this blog is applicable to what I am trying to do. Could you please send me the formulas for the breads?
Thank you,
Roger
Amy says
Greetings from northeast CT. I have recently discovered your blog and I’m devouring it, thank you, thank you. I would love to receive the recipes for babka and povetica.
amy says
Oh wait! I see the formulas are in the post. Did you add them later? Is there something else?
mc.farine says
Hello Amy, I just sent them to you. Hope you got them!
Enjoy,
MC
Dano says
Thanks for the post! Got here from a Breadtopia YouTube video.
Would it be possible to receive the one babka & povetica recipes?
Thanks!
mc.farine says
Sorry for the delay. Just sent them to you. Please let me know if you get them.
Enjoy! MC
Ari says
Hi! Thank you for this post; I’m now trying to make high-hydration challah with this technique, and it’s helped tremendously, especially since I am using even higher eggs and sugar, which make the dough quite difficult for me. I do love babka too, though — would you send the recipes?
Mark Woodward says
Hello MC, Could you please send me the two formulas. Many thanks. : )
Judy Kennedy says
Hi MC,
I’m so glad I found your blog. I have spent days on your blog; I love it. I’m an avid home baker. Thank you!!!
I had a couple questions:
1. will you be working on the recipe for Keith Guisto’s power bread using sprouted grain?
2. Please may I have the recipe for the Babka?
I would be so grateful.
Thank you,
Judy K.